Is the Civitas Institute at UT-Austin the nose of a
Koch-owned camel?
During the past year a number
of articles were written about the stealth installation at UT Austin of a
right-wing institute “dedicated to the study and teaching of individual
liberty, limited government, private enterprise and free markets.” [Texas
Tribune, Kate McGee, 8-26-2021] Originally dubbed the Liberty Institute, but
finally named the Civitas Institute, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick raised the
possibility that the goals of the new institute might be more pointedly
political. “I will not stand by and let looney Marxist UT professors poison the
minds of young students with Critical Race Theory.” Patrick wrote on the social
media platform Twitter. “We banned it in publicly funded K-12 and we will ban
it in publicly funded higher ed. That’s
why we created the Liberty Institute at UT.” [reported in the Texas Tribune,
McGee 2-16-2022] Two days later the
Texas Tribune also reported “Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick said Friday that he will push
to end professor tenure for all new hires at Texas Public universities and
colleges in an effort to combat faculty members who he says ‘indoctrinate’
students with teachings about critical race theory.”[McGee 2-18-2022] On June
13, 2022 the Texas Tribune announced that Justin Dyer, a UT graduate, had been
selected as the director of the Civitas Institute. Dyer is a self-described “pro-life
evangelical”. [McGee 6-13-2022]
Another set of relevant
relationships arise from the fact that Lt. Gov. Patrick is a member of the
board of directors of the Texas Conservative Coalition Research Institute. That board also includes Comptroller Glen Hegar, Railroad Commissioner Christi Craddick, plus 9 state
senators and 10 members of the Texas House. In addition, 13 members of TCCRI’s
board are registered lobbyists, including such prominent ones as Mike Toomey
and Lara Keel. But most importantly, in my opinion, is one other board
member-lobbyist by the name of Bill Oswald.
Mr. Oswald carries the title of Vice Chair of TCCRI. He is also an employee of and a lobbyist in
Texas for the nine subsidiaries of Koch Industries. Based on information in
TCCRI’s tax returns, Mr. Oswald is the longest-serving board member of that
organization.
In addition to pointing out
the involvement of Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick with the Liberty Institute, the Texas
Tribune also reported on the involvement of two wealthy Texas UT-Austin Alumni
and businessmen--Bob Rowling and Bud Brigham. “Rowling
confirmed to the Tribune through his assistant that he is involved with the
project and said that Brigham, an oil company executive and fervent promoter of
the writer Ayn Rand, was the real leader on this.” [Texas Tribune, McGee,
8-26-2021). The Texas Tribune also reported that “Brigham donated $10,000 to
Patrick’s campaign” after the Civitas Institute was funded [McGee, 8-26-2021].
In addition, Emma Schkloven reported that Rowling
gave $150,000 to Patrick “last summer” [Austin Monthly, Emma Schkloven, May 2022]. Schkloven
also claimed that “It’s widely believed the main players will be brought in
from Austin-based The Texas Public Policy Foundation, a darling of Patrick’s.”
In view of the reporting
described above, I will stick my neck out, and make the following
conjecture: The major part of the
Civitas Institute endeavor is a result of funding by, and interrelationships
with, the Koch-funded donor network, the Texas Public Policy Foundation (TPPF)
and the Texas Conservative Coalition Research Institute (TCCRI), with Dan
Patrick playing a pivotal role. Part of the reporting that appeared in the
Texas Tribune, other
related articles, information from federal tax returns and the Texas Ethics
Commission, and previous work I did on TCCRI, is summarized in following
diagram. Several comments on the diagram follow beneath it.
1.
The $6.8 million
from the Koch Foundation to TPPF, the inclusion of a Koch Industries employee,
Bill Oswald, on the board of TCCRI, and TPPF and TCCRI board members’
contributions to Lt. Gov. Patrick bind closely together some of the main actors
in this set of relationships.
2.
The reported
contributions of Rowling and Brigham to Patrick, and Brigham’s donations to
TPPF, further tie Patrick and TPPF to the Civitas project.
3.
Donations by TPPF
board member Doug Deason and the Deason Family Foundation to elements of the Koch network
and to TPPF further binds together these interests. The organization Stand
Together, which superseded the Seminar Network, is sometimes referred to simply
as the “Koch Network.” According to an article on Wikipedia, the Chairman and
CEO of Stand Together is Brian Hooks. Hooks “previously served as executive
director of the Mercatus Center at George Mason
University.” Along with Hooks, other members of the board of directors of the Mercatus Center are Charles Koch, its founder and major
funder, and Richard Fink, a former executive VP of Koch Industries.
4.
The substantial
contribution from the Deason Foundation to Turning
Point USA ($760,000), and its subgroup Professor Watch List, supports the
notion that the Libertarian actors in TPPF, along with Charles Koch and other
members of the Koch funding network, are still working to reverse what they
deem as the leftist tendencies among American universities. Or, in the words of
Lt. Gov. Patrick, “loony Marxist UT professors.”
5.
The major
involvement of Charles Koch with the Mercatus Center
and its housing within George Mason University, and his direct and indirect
involvement with the network of individuals and organizations promoting the
Civitas Institute inevitably raises the question as to whether the Mercatus Center is being used as a role model for the
Civitas Institute. See this link
for an understanding of what this suggestion might imply.
Note: Most of
the numerical data shown in the diagram came from Foundations Online and the
Texas Ethics Commission.
Much has previously been
written about the Koch family support and influence in numerous institutions of
higher education in the U.S. , especially in the South (see Charles Koch
gave $90 million to influence higher ed in the South, Alex Kotch, Dec. 3,
2015. here)
Shawn Otto, in his book The
War on Science: Who’s Waging it, Why it Matters, What
we can do about it includes the Koch-founded Americans for Prosperity as
one of the major organizations engaged in climate-change denial (p. 284). As noted on the diagram above, Doug Deason has made substantial contributions to Americans for
Prosperity. A look at the board members of TPPF and the business clients of
lobbyist-board members of TCCRI (see my attached paper) leaves little doubt
that climate-change denial is consistent with the stated goals of Civitas
Institute, namely “individual liberty, limited government, private enterprise
and free markets.” Limited government is often used as a synonym for less
environmental regulation.
As noted above, Doug Deason is not only a major supporter of TPPF, but also has
contributed some $760,000 to Turning Point USA (TPUSA). According to Jane Mayer, in an article in the
New Yorker, the founder of TPUSA, Charles Kirk, “has spoken and fund-raised at
various closed-door energy-industry gatherings, including those of the 2017
board meeting of the National Mining Association and the 2016 annual meeting of
the Independent Petroleum Association of America.” Mayer also points out that
TPUSA “runs an online ‘Professor Watch List’ that targets professors it
believes are liberal, blamed ‘leftist professors’ in its booklet for having
‘perpetuated’ these ‘myths’ [about the effects of climate change]”.
There are just too many ties
between the advocates of the Civitas Institute, various elements of the Koch
Network, the Texas Public Policy Foundation and its supporters, and Lt. Gov.
Dan Patrick to rest assured that its main purpose is to promote the interests
of the general citizenry of the State of Texas. The effort to establish the
Civitas Institute seems more aligned with past endeavors of the Kochs and their
partners, including Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, in increasing their control over
Texas political processes in general and higher education in particular.